Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Despite changing composition settings for replies to be above quote

  • 10 replies
  • 1 has this problem
  • 8 views
  • Last reply by Rich-J

more options

So since moving to a new PC a few weeks back I'm struggling to solve what seems to be a simple issue with Thunderbird. Namely, when I go to reply the reply starts below the previous message. Before you just comment a link to the post from a while back where someone has screenshotted the composition settings, I've already changed the setting to 'start my reply above the quote' and it still does the reply below.

-I have ticked to automatically quote the original message when replying. -Start reply above quote is selected. -and currently signature is selected below reply and above quote.

Have I missed something simple here?

Thank you for your time.

So since moving to a new PC a few weeks back I'm struggling to solve what seems to be a simple issue with Thunderbird. Namely, when I go to reply the reply starts below the previous message. Before you just comment a link to the post from a while back where someone has screenshotted the composition settings, I've already changed the setting to 'start my reply above the quote' and it still does the reply below. -I have ticked to automatically quote the original message when replying. -Start reply above quote is selected. -and currently signature is selected below reply and above quote. Have I missed something simple here? Thank you for your time.
Attached screenshots

Chosen solution

Open Config. editor (Options/General in 78 or Options/Advanced/General in 68), type reply in the search, and look at the value of mail.identity.idN.reply_on_top, where N = 1,2,3... depending on the account. The value should be 1 to have the reply above the quote, or 0 (zero) to have it below the quote. What are your current values? Right-click, Modify, if the value isn't 1.

Read this answer in context 👍 1

All Replies (10)

more options

Chosen Solution

Open Config. editor (Options/General in 78 or Options/Advanced/General in 68), type reply in the search, and look at the value of mail.identity.idN.reply_on_top, where N = 1,2,3... depending on the account. The value should be 1 to have the reply above the quote, or 0 (zero) to have it below the quote. What are your current values? Right-click, Modify, if the value isn't 1.

more options

That did the job perfectly, thank you.

I'm guessing it was because I had two email addresses in the same account, it had ID1 with a value of 1 but ID2 had a value of 0. Everytime I changed it in the settings it was just changing ID1.

more options

TBird 78.4.0 on Win 10.

Same problem but mail.identity.idN.reply_on_top, is already set to 1.

more options

Follow-up:

3 lines up, this was 0, reset to 1, same problem.

mail.identity.default.reply_on_top;1

more options

Hmm unsure with yours, all of your IDs are set to 1 so it should be on top. I wonder if sfhowes has the answer.

more options

Who/what is sfhowes?

more options

He's the one who posted the answer above.

more options

OIC...

more options

Try safe mode (Help/Restart with add-ons disabled), in case there's an add-on, especially one involving signatures, causing the preference to be overridden. Try normal mode without signatures, if you have them (they are defined for each account).

more options

OK, had tried turning (all 3) add-ons off individually with no change.

Several restarts later the new version of Signature Switch seems to be the culprit.

Will all disabled, the quote is now correct, cursor at top and colour = blue.

Thanks for your help.

Richard